Gender based violence and harmful traditional practice

 Definitions and concepts

Gender: Social construct  of  norms, roles, and relations for males and females for behaviour and action of a given society
Sex: Biological difference between men and women.
Violence:  “ intentional use of physical force or power, threatened or actual, resulting in injury death, psychological harm, mal development, and deprivation”.
Harmful Traditional Practices (HTPs): a ‘’traditional practices which violate and negatively affect the physical, sexual or psychological well-being…: eg FGM/C, abduction and child marriage

Harmful Traditional Practices (HTPs) conti….

Causes of HTP 
Root, intermediate and immediate causes 
A. Root causes : 
Low societal consciousness results that undermine women and children
Deep rooted imbalances in power and gender relations and inequality
B. Intermediate causes: Results of root causes and increase vulnerability. These include:
Poverty and Economic Inequalities
Lack of Education and Training
Inaccessibility to quality health facilities and services
Religious and cultural factors
C. Immediate Causes :  Limited access to information

Consequences of HTPs
Health Consequences: bleeding, infection, difficulty and complications during delivery, pain, fistula, HIV/AIDS transmission, infertility etc
Economic dependency: The debilitating effects of HTPs in turn limit opportunities
Psycho-social Consequences: High levels stress, unhappiness, and unhealthy relationships with partners and stigma by society
Human right violations: HTPs go to the extent of threatening the lives of women and children thereby affecting their right to life
Limiting one’s life choices: Enforce inferior status and the submissive role

Types of harmful traditional practices

Female genital mutilation (FGM/C) or cutting involves surgical removal of parts or all of the most sensitive female genital organs
Causes reproductive, sexual, and urinary dysfunctions
A human rights violation regardless of a specific law against it
FGM in girls and women (15-49 years) is 65% (EDHS 2016)
Tigray and Gambella have the lowest prevalence (24% and 33%, 
Somali and Afar regions have  the highest prevalence (99% and 91%)

Types of FGM

TYPE I clitoridectomy: Partial/total excision of the hood of the clitoris.
TYPE II excision/Sunna type: Partial/or total excision of the labia minora clitoris. 
TYPE III infibulation: Excision of labia majora together with the above two act
TYPE IV:  the above and others like pricking, piercing, or incision of the clitoris and/or labia; stretching of the clitoris and/or labia; cauterization by burning clitoris and surrounding tissues etc.





FGM related complications
Short Term Compilications                              

●Severe pain 
●Haemorrhage
●Infection/sepsis
 ●Acute urinary retention
●Shock

 Long Term Compilications
  ●  Clitoral neuroma
   ●Menstrual disorder
 ●Vagina adhesion and obstruction
   ●Sexual problem
   ●Reproductive & recurrent UTIs 
   ●Infertility
 ●Chronic difficulty with urination,
  ●stress urinary incontinence, 
    ●Vesico-vaginal fistula. 

HTPS...

Child Marriage: Marriage before age 18 years  a risk for violence, exploitation, and abuse. 
Abduction:  Forcibly taking of  someone for  purpose of marriage 
Nutritional taboos: factors place limits in one way or another on the intake of food 
Gender-based violence : can be  physical, sexual, or psychological harm or suffering, whether occurring in private or public life
It involves not only direct force but also threats, intimidation, and coercion. 
Physical violence, e.g.: slapping, hitting, pushing, choking, shaking, spitting, restraining, use of weapons
Sexual violence, e.g. rape,  forced marriage, forced abortion, FGM, trafficking, incest
Psychological violence, e.g. Verbal, intimidation/threats, emotional violence, constant criticism, humiliation,

Epidemiology of GBV
GBV occurs in  30% of cohabiting 15-19 year adolescent women with 10%-30% in high income to 43% in low-income countries. 
 In Ethiopia,34% of ever-married women experienced spousal physical, sexual, or emotional violence.
 Physical and emotional violence were experienced by 24% each, and sexual violence by10% (EDHS 2016). 
Causes of GBV
GBV is caused by a combination of factors
The ecological framework is used to understand the multiple causes of GBV and their interrelationship.

Ecological frame, causes of GBV. Source Heise, 1988 


Causes continued…

The Individual Factors

  ●Young age (early marriage)
  ●Pregnancy
  ●low level of education,
  ●Past experiences of violence and 
  ●attitudes of violence as acceptable behaviour. 

The Relationship Factors
  ●focus on women/girls relationships with family and their peers. 
  ●Men with multiple partners, 
  ●Disparities in education status between partners and 
  ●Family blaming the girls instead of the man for sexual violence.

Causes and consequences continued...

Community Level Factors
●Social relationships in
●school, 
●workplace, 
 ●neighbourhood. 
●A society that challenge violence , low GBV level 

Soceital Level Factors
●Cultural and social norms for gender
●Higher GBV  with the household of men only decision-making powers
●Ideology of male sexual entitlement is societal level factors  

Consequences and responses of GBV

Responses 
Primary prevention:
Increasing community awareness of HTPs & challenging harmful gender norms 
Secondary prevention:
Early identification of survivors, Evaluation and treatment of injuries
Prompt referral to appropriate services
Tertiary prevention: Mitigate negative impacts of violence 
Counseling, HIV testing, PEP, Emergency contraception
STI prophylaxis, including Hepatitis 

Understanding gender Value Clarification

Values: Sets of principles and rules that help and guide in decision making and orient oneself within a governing system
Identify them as gender or sex:
●Most building-site workers in Ethiopia are men
●Women often take responsibility for household chores
●Men are naturally responsible to protect and care for the family
●Boys are naturally active in public while girls remain shy
●Wife battering is normal, in fact, it helps to discipline the wife
●Girls/women should take responsibility for the violence they suffered
●Women should tolerate violence to keep the family together
●Forcing a female partner into sex can’t be considered rape

Health systems response to GBV

Health sector is a key entry point for care and referral
GBV survivors should be taken care with an individual context
Health care providers should provide service 
Based on a gendered understanding of violence against women 
Focus on the human rights and safety of the victims
In an integrated approach, 
Takes into account the relationship between victims, perpetrators, children and their wider social environment.
Services aim at avoiding secondary victimization.
Services aim at victim empowerment and economic independence 
Services allow protection and support services 
Services address the specific needs of the victim
Health care providers should have 
Skills to identify survivors and do proper examinations,
Do risk assessments, and provide medical care and safety planning. medical care. This process

Multi-sectoral Response to GBV

























Multi-sectoral response
Multi-sectoral response -social, psychological, economic, and legal aspects 
Health care providers  refer survivors to other services for immediate needs and prevent future incidents of violence
Principles to prevent and respond to acts of violence :
Respect: for the rights, and dignity of the survivor 
Confidentiality:  except when faces imminent risk 
Safety and security: physical safety of the survivor and supporters
Mandatory reporting of suspected GBV cases  should be balanced with principles of autonomy and confidentiality 
Prevent re-victimization of GBV: in taking testimonials 
Protection of staff working with survivors: psychological support

Gender Transformation and Continuum

Gender transformation refers to efforts to change gender and social norms to address inequalities
Gender Continuum
Gender continuum is a tool for designers and implementers to use in planning how to integrate gender into their programs/policies














Gender Continuum Categories

Gender Blind: Absence of any proactive consideration of the larger gender environment 
Gender Aware: Explicit recognition of local gender differences, norms, and relations and their importance 
Gender Exploitative: Approaches to project design, implementation, and evaluation 
Gender Accommodating: Approaches acknowledge the role of gender norms and inequities and seek to develop actions that adjust to and often compensate for them
Gender Transformative: Approaches actively strive to examine, question, and change rigid gender norms and imbalance of power as a means of reaching health as well as gender equity objectives

SUMMERY

What do Gender and  Sex mean?
Describe  GBV and HTP 
Describe types of FGM
Explain the ecological frame for the cause of GBV
What are the consequences and responses of GBV?
Describe the gender continuum category

Comments